| Name | Total | Name | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mac Gillivary | 1 | McKenzie | 6 |
| MacDonald | 9 | McLaws | 4 |
| Macko | 1 | McLean | 1 |
| Maden | 2 | McLeod | 2 |
| Malmberg | 10 | McMaster | 9 |
| Mann | 1 | McMullen | 3 |
| Manning | 8 | McPherson | 1 |
| Marion | 3 | McVicar | 9 |
| Marlow | 2 | Meredith | 1 |
| Marshall | 15 | Middlebrook | 1 |
| Martin | 1 | Millen | 1 |
| Mason | 3 | Miller | 10 |
| Massie | 1 | Milne | 1 |
| Masters | 1 | Moffat | 1 |
| Maxwell | 3 | MonPetit | 1 |
| McCleery | 1 | Monroe | 1 |
| McConachie | 2 | Monteith | 17 |
| McConnell | 1 | Moon | 1 |
| McCuaig | 4 | Moore | 4 |
| McFadden | 18 | More | 1 |
| McGill | 3 | Moreau | 1 |
| McGillis | 1 | Motley | 15 |
| McGillivray | 4 | Mumby | 3 |
| McGonegal | 1 | Murdoch | 1 |
| McHardy | 5 | Murphy | 1 |
| McHardy (Mother's Nee Name Unknown) | 1 | Murray | 1 |
| McKee | 6 | - | - |